Weld Macro Testing: Compare Scopes for Australian Fabricators
Compare the examination scope before choosing a laboratory
QMS and AECTL offer direct laboratory macro-examination services; LMATS presents macro testing within a broader welder/performance-qualification pathway.[1][2][3] Compare preparation, examination evidence and acceptance reporting separately from witnessed welding and additional tests.

QMS Asset Integrity
- Service scope: QMS performs macro examination at its Largs North laboratory.[1]
- Coupon preparation and examination evidence: Its process covers cutting at the specified location, optional mounting, grinding, polishing, etching and low-magnification examination, with photographs in a formal report.[1] Ask how identification and orientation will be preserved during preparation.
- Acceptance reporting and accreditation scope: QMS explicitly reports against applicable acceptance criteria and states NATA Accreditation No. 18957, Site 26037, under ISO/IEC 17025:2017. Accredited work is conditional on the quoted examination falling within its published site scope.[1]
AECTL
- Service scope: AECTL advertises macro examination covering weld profile, penetration, fusion, the heat-affected zone (HAZ), cracks, porosity and inclusions.[2]
- Coupon preparation and examination evidence: AECTL explicitly offers high-resolution imaging.[2] Ask it to specify preparation, section orientation and marking requirements in the quotation.
- Acceptance reporting and accreditation scope: AECTL advertises expert reporting, ISO 17025/NATA accreditation and testing aligned with named standards.[2] AECTL’s page does not explicitly promise an acceptance decision against nominated criteria.[2] Request that decision and confirmation of accreditation coverage for the quoted work.
LMATS
- Service scope: LMATS offers witnessed or supervised coupon welding, followed by visual examination and, where required, NDT and mechanical testing including macro examination.[3]
- Coupon preparation and examination evidence: Macro testing is listed within that pathway.[3] Request preparation, orientation requirements and macro photographs explicitly.
- Acceptance reporting and accreditation scope: LMATS states ISO/IEC 17025 and ISO 17020 accreditation.[3] Ask for the macro-specific acceptance-report format and confirmation of accreditation coverage for the quoted examination.
Agree the scope before anyone cuts the coupon
Put the examination question, proposed section and required report in writing before authorising cutting. QMS describes cutting at a specified location and reporting against applicable acceptance criteria.[1] Those two decisions should be linked from the outset.
Use the following as an agreement checklist, not a shared laboratory submission form. Ask QMS, AECTL or LMATS to confirm detailed specimen identifiers, orientation-marking procedures, custody and remnant arrangements.
- Purpose: State the weld question and whether the order covers standalone macro examination or a broader witnessed qualification service.
- Location and orientation: Attach a sketch or marked photograph showing the proposed cut, examination face and area of interest.
- Identity: Agree how the coupon, weld, parent metal and orientation will remain identifiable.
- Preparation: Confirm who cuts the coupon and what laboratory preparation and etching are included.
- Evidence: Specify photographs, scale or magnification information, and documented observations.
- Acceptance: Name the applicable WPS/PQR identifiers, project specification and acceptance criteria; request an explicit assessment.
- Remaining material: Agree authorisation for further cuts, retention, return and disposal.
Let the weld question determine the section location
Procedure qualification, production verification, failure investigation and repair verification are distinct applications listed by QMS.[1] State which question the examination needs to answer, then ask the laboratory to confirm whether the proposed section location addresses it.
WeldFabWorld’s technical guide describes a transverse section cut perpendicular to the weld axis.[4] Treat this as background guidance, not a universal cutting instruction or a submission condition issued by the chosen laboratory.
On the proposed sketch, identify the section line, examination face and feature of interest. Ask the laboratory to accept or amend that proposal before cutting, and to identify whether additional sections should be included. This is a practical agreement step, not a published provider requirement.
Keep the conclusion bounded: evidence from an examined cross-section concerns that section; it does not establish that every part of the weld is defect-free.[1][4]
Keep coupon identity and orientation unambiguous
Agree an identification method before submission, including how orientation information will survive cutting and preparation. Suggested fields are:
- Coupon and weld references: identifiers to carry through to the photographs and report.
- Section position: the intended cut location, linked to the coupon reference.
- Orientation sketch: the weld, parent metal, intended examination face and relevant directions.
- Document reference: the applicable WPS or project document and its revision.
These are proposed agreement fields, not provider-mandated labels. Ask the laboratory to confirm its requirements for label formats, heat or lot references, WPS/PQR identifiers, welder identity and orientation-marking procedures, and how the examined face will remain linked to the final report.
Specify the prepared section and image evidence
QMS describes cutting, optional mounting, progressive grinding and polishing, then chemical etching to reveal macrostructure.[1] Its low-magnification examination, typically up to 10x, assesses profile, penetration, fusion, HAZ extent and discontinuities such as cracks, porosity and lack of fusion.[1]
Request the preparation scope as part of the quotation rather than treating a cut face alone as the agreed deliverable. Leave the material-dependent preparation and etching procedure to the laboratory.
Make the image requirements explicit. QMS confirms photographs in a formal report; AECTL confirms high-resolution imaging and reporting.[1][2] Request macro photographs from LMATS as part of the agreed qualification-testing deliverables.
Ask the laboratory to confirm photograph scale calibration. Agree image labels, the examined face, magnification information, required views and whether a scale is needed. Ask for documented observations as well as images, so the report addresses the examination question.
Keep the order focused on the section-based penetration and fusion evidence described by QMS and AECTL.[1][2] Do not assume chemical PMI or nondestructive thickness measurement is included; keep any request for those services separate from the macro-examination scope.
Agree acceptance reporting and check accreditation scope
Before testing, name the applicable WPS or project specification, examination standard and edition, and acceptance criteria in the written scope. QMS explicitly reports against applicable acceptance criteria; AECTL describes testing aligned with standards including AS 2207, ISO 5817 and ASTM E340.[1][2]
Keep the examination method separate from the acceptance question. Request a conclusion against the agreed criteria, rather than relying on a method reference alone. For AECTL and LMATS, make that requested acceptance statement an explicit quotation item rather than assuming their reporting commitments match QMS’s.
Check accreditation against the actual quotation. Ask which laboratory site, examination method and activities fall within the relevant scope. QMS supplies accreditation and site numbers; AECTL and LMATS state accreditation status.[1][2][3] Request the corresponding scope documents when comparing quotations.
For ASME Section IX work, identify whether the order concerns procedure qualification or welder performance qualification. Before cutting, obtain the laboratory’s written confirmation of the applicable edition, examination clause and acceptance basis. Carry those agreed references into the quotation and final report; do not select a clause from a supplier summary alone.
Decide what happens to specimens and remaining material
QMS describes macro examination as destructive.[1] Agree what may be cut and what should be kept before authorising the work. Ask QMS, AECTL or LMATS to confirm ownership, storage, return, disposal and retention arrangements for prepared sections and remnants.
Put the handling agreement in writing, covering:
- Who can authorise additional cuts.
- Who owns the prepared section and untested remnants.
- Which material will be stored or returned, and which may be disposed of.
- The retention period and instructions when it ends.
For an investigation or repair assessment, consider requesting written approval before further cutting. Treat this as a safeguard to agree with the laboratory, not an existing laboratory policy.
Compare like-for-like written quotations
Send each laboratory the same scope and ask it to mark preparation, images, observations, acceptance reporting, accreditation coverage and remnant handling as included, excluded or separately priced.
Ask QMS for a quoted turnaround. AECTL advertises “fast turnaround” for macro examination without a duration; LMATS says most welder qualification tests can be completed within an agreed timeframe from coupon receipt, with results advised immediately after completion.[1][2][3] Compare agreed delivery dates, not speed claims.
Request prices, priced packages, minimum orders, cancellation terms and refund terms from QMS, AECTL or LMATS in writing alongside the technical scope.
Choose between a standalone examination and a broader qualification service first. Before authorising cutting, obtain agreement on the section location, orientation and report needed to answer the weld question.
References
- Macro Examination Australia | Weld Macroscopic Testing | QMS Asset Integrity (qmsndt.com.au)
- Macro Examination Services | AECTL Weld & Material Analysis (aectl.com.au)
- Welder testing – Performance Qualification – LMATS (lmats.com.au)
- Macro vs Micro Tests in Welding – Why They Matter – Welding Fabrication World (weldfabworld.com, 2025)