Field Roof Uplift Testing: Requirements for US Building Owners
Before commissioning field roof uplift testing, have your consultant document the roof assembly, justify the method, agree on test areas and acceptance criteria, and assign investigation, reporting and watertight reinstatement responsibilities. Separate the selected method’s requirements from additional owner-requested safeguards. [1][3]

- Method requirements: Identify the applicable procedures, acceptance criteria and investigation duties. For FM testing, these include contract provisions, owner-representative witnessing, roofing-professional involvement and reporting. [1][3]
- Owner-requested safeguards: Put location plans, authorization for additional work, stop conditions, repair responsibility, final acceptance authority and requested report contents in writing. These project assignments do not replace the method’s requirements. [1][3]
1. Define the concern and document the assembly
Start with what needs verification. As Professional Roofing explains, ASTM E907-25 assesses adhesion between an adhered membrane and the surface directly beneath it. Insulation breakage or separation from the deck, and fastener backout or breakage, fall outside its scope; encountering them can make the result inconclusive. [3]
Ask your consultant to assemble this record before recommending a method, because these characteristics affect FM Data Sheet 1-52 testing, visual construction observation and exception pathways: [1]
- Roof covering: Membrane type, attachment method and any base sheet. [1]
- Underlying assembly: Insulation attachment, deck type, and deck gauge or strength as applicable. [1]
- Fastening: Fastener spacing and which layers are mechanically attached. [1]
- Roof history: Roof age and whether the work involves a new roof, recover or reroof. [1]
- Wind and layout: Roof-zone geometry, design wind speed and whether the site falls within FM’s defined tropical-cyclone-prone region. [1]
Have the consultant flag unresolved details and explain whether they prevent determining that the proposed test fits the suspected weakness or that another FM verification pathway applies. [1][3]
2. Require a method-selection explanation
ASTM E907-25 and FM Data Sheet 1-52 have different scopes and interpretation frameworks. A proposal saying only “uplift test” does not resolve which applies. [1][3]
ASTM E907-25
- Purpose: Assesses adhesion between an adhered membrane and its immediate substrate—not every connection through the roof assembly. [3]
- Applicable concern: Bonding at the membrane underside, within the adhesive, at the adhesive-to-substrate interface or within the substrate itself. [3]
- Interpretation: Uses failure and suspected-failure criteria; maximum membrane deflection is no longer an acceptance criterion. [3]
FM Data Sheet 1-52
- Purpose: Provides FM’s field-verification framework, including negative-pressure testing, bonded-uplift testing and visual construction observation. [1]
- Applicable configuration: FM’s field tests are not applicable to metal panel roofs, ballasted roofs, or mechanically fastened covers with fasteners spaced more than 2 ft apart in either direction. Have the consultant check the roof system against Table 2.2.2-1 and identify the applicable test or alternative verification pathway. [1]
- Interpretation: Applies FM’s pathway-specific procedures and acceptance provisions, rather than ASTM’s adhesion criteria. [1][3]
Name the exact document: ASTM E907-25 or FM Data Sheet 1-52. Professional Roofing reports ASTM E907-25 was reinstated in January and recommends using it instead of previous editions. Its author also recommends it over FM 1-52, while FM maintains its separate framework. The consultant should resolve that difference for the project rather than combine the methods’ criteria. [1][3]
3. Check FM observation and exception pathways
For FM clients, FM Data Sheet 1-52 instructs the client to contact the local FM office before uplift testing or roofing work. Have the consultant document whether an exception or visual construction observation (VCO) pathway applies before authorizing testing. [1]
FM’s regional trigger combines both an FM-defined tropical-cyclone-prone location and a design wind speed of at least 100 mph. For new, recovered or reroofed above-deck assemblies at those sites, FM calls for satisfactory testing under its specified testing sections or VCO under Section 2.5—not observation as an unrestricted substitute. [1]
The directly fastened-cover exception covers new single-ply covers, or multi-ply covers with a mechanically fastened base sheet, fastened directly to a qualifying deck, with roof-cover fastener spacing verified as adequate. Verification may use visual identification or nondestructive examination, such as metal detection. [1]
Request a written explanation identifying the applicable provision, cover-to-deck configuration, qualifying deck characteristics and evidence of adequate fastener spacing—or explaining how the proposed VCO meets Section 2.5. “Mechanically attached roof” alone does not establish eligibility for the exception. [1]
4. Agree on test areas and site readiness
Ask for an annotated roof plan marking proposed field, perimeter and corner locations, assembly changes, and the assembly each test is intended to represent. FM Data Sheet 1-52 provides a framework for dividing roof areas; the proposal should translate it into a site-specific layout. [1]
- Fix the test count. Have the consultant state the proposed number of tests, cite the applicable provisions of the current method, and show how the locations correspond to roof-area divisions and roof zones. [1]
- Resolve positioning. Ask the consultant to explain placement relative to supports and deck joints under the selected method. Chamberlin’s 2010 article discusses chamber positioning, but it is historical background, not a current placement requirement. [2]
- Document readiness. Include access, roof protection, compatible preparation and sealing, and applicable adhesive-cure and environmental conditions. FM’s appendices address preparation and operating conditions; require method-specific instructions rather than importing older recipes or limits. [1]
- Control additional work. State who can authorize extra locations or tests, keeping the agreed scope distinguishable from subsequent investigation. [1][3]
5. Set acceptance criteria and stop conditions
Require a written acceptance plan identifying the documented design-load basis, agreed pressures, pressure sequence and interpretation criteria. Professional Roofing says interested parties should agree on test pressures before testing. [3]
ASTM E907-25 has a specific default: unless construction documents specifically state otherwise, the maximum test pressure is the roof area’s code-prescribed allowable-stress-design wind load. [3] For FM work, Data Sheet 1-52 Section 2.2.4 sets the required passing uplift test pressure at 1.25 times the design wind pressure for each roof zone; Section 2.2.5 provides an alternative table subject to its stated conditions. Have the consultant document the applicable zone pressures and calculation basis rather than substitute ASTM criteria or historical FM pressure tables. [1]
The plan should distinguish these ASTM outcomes:
- Failure: A tear, puncture, fracture or other through-membrane opening inside the chamber. [3]
- Deformation alone: Visible blistering, ballooning, bowing, upward deflection or membrane-layer separation is not, by itself, failure. [3]
- Suspected failure: A blister, balloon or membrane-layer separation whose diameter grows by more than 50% between pressure increments may qualify. Failure or suspected failure calls for further investigation. [3]
ASTM E907-25 removed deflection measurement and maximum-deflection acceptance criteria. An older deflection limit should not appear as its pass/fail rule. [3]
Separately, agree on when pressure increases stop, what happens after failure, suspected failure or an out-of-scope condition, and who authorizes resumption or decides final acceptance. These are project assignments, distinct from the selected method’s procedural requirements. [1][3]
6. Assign witnessing and investigation
For FM testing, the owner’s representative is to witness the work, and testing requirements are to be included in the building contract and applicable roofing contracts or subcontracts. FM also requires a roofing professional to conduct test cuts in failed or suspect areas. [1]
Keep required investigation separate from optional retesting. Failure or suspected failure under ASTM E907-25 calls for investigation, such as a roof test cut. By contrast, insulation separation or fastener backout falls outside its adhesion scope and can make a result inconclusive; an additional test may then be conducted rather than being automatically required. [3]
Name who authorizes additional investigation, records findings and determines final disposition. Distinguish the witness, the roofing professional performing cuts and the acceptance authority so attendance is not treated as approval. [1][3]
7. Assign watertight reinstatement responsibility
FM Data Sheet 1-52 requires a roofing professional to be present to repair failed test areas and restore them to a watertight condition. [1]
Before commissioning, name the repair party and assign responsibility for test cuts, preparation damage, failed areas and additional investigative openings. Specify roof-system-appropriate reinstatement rather than equipment removal alone. [1]
The superseded July 2012 FM guidance called for prompt watertight patching to prevent wet insulation; it is historical context, not a substitute for the repair requirements applicable to the roof now. Have the consultant identify those requirements in the scope. [1][4]
Request repair records and photographs showing each affected location, work performed and completed condition. Treat these as owner-requested deliverables unless the applicable method expressly requires them; FM’s full-report requirement does not establish that every requested repair record is mandatory. [1]
8. Require a report supporting a defined acceptance decision
FM calls for recorded results, a full report from the uplift-test contractor, and forwarding test or VCO results to the local FM servicing office. Make that obligation explicit—not merely a “pass” certificate. [1]
Request these report contents as owner deliverables, rather than treating every item as a verified mandatory method field: [1]
- Each location and its assembly; exact method and edition. [1]
- Equipment, calibration and pressure measurement; applicable weather and roof-surface observations; pressure sequence and maximum pressure reached. [1]
- Observed behavior, failure mode, photographs, investigation findings, repairs and each area’s final disposition. [1]
Require the conclusion to identify what was assessed and against which project criterion, distinguish inconclusive or unresolved conditions from accepted results, and name the acceptance authority. [1][3]
Do not treat a field result as a laboratory product rating or a promise of whole-roof wind resistance. Professional Roofing reports that an eight-company, 24-test interlaboratory study found no correlation between field-test deflection measurements and FM Approvals’ laboratory-derived uplift approvals. [3]
If storm-damage causation is at issue, FM advises against using field tests to determine the cause unless comparable tests occurred immediately before the storm and the absence of pre-storm roof-cover damage or deficiencies can be proven. [1]
References
- DS 1-52 Field Verification of Roof Wind Uplift Resistance ( … (fm.com)
- Roof Uplift Testing: Know the Parameters & Use the Information Wisely (chamberlinltd.com, 2010)
- A field uplift testing update by Mark S. Graham 2026-05-01 | Professional Roofing (professionalroofing.net, 2026)
- July 2012 Page 1 of 24 FIELD VERIFICATION OF ROOF WIND UPLIFT RESISTANCE (hinarratives.com)