HROUS

Historic Building Recording: Compare for Owners in England

Advertisement

CFA Archaeology explicitly offers WSI preparation and monitoring during works; Heritage Unlimited explicitly offers Levels 1–4 recording, report submission and archive deposits. Compare their quotations against the planning condition—not simply the price of a survey. [3][4]

Low angle view of the historic Box Elder County Courthouse with columns and blue sky, Brigham City, Utah.
Advertisement

Start with the condition: what must happen before works?

Brief both providers against the decision notice. Identify the recording level, affected fabric, written scheme of investigation (WSI) requirement, approval route and trigger points for work. [1][2][5]

Check the pre-commencement requirements. Camden’s guidance gives an example condition prohibiting commencement until recording and analysis have been secured and implemented under a WSI submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority (LPA). Development must follow that scheme or subsequent written variations. Commissioning a report alone does not meet that wording; this is Camden’s example, not a standard condition throughout England. [1]

Bassetlaw advises discussing the proposed recording level with its planning department and recording before development begins. [2] Historic England’s recording guide, more than three years old, recommends identifying existing knowledge, proposed changes, research gaps and the required recording level in the brief or WSI for LPA agreement. [5]

Send each provider the same condition wording and proposals. Ask them to distinguish included responsibilities from tasks needing separate instruction or authority agreement.

Advertisement

CFA Archaeology vs Heritage Unlimited

CFA Archaeology

Recording scope: CFA lists initial appraisals, standing-building surveys, reports and structural or architectural monitoring during development. [3] Ask it to identify the recording level and outputs in its quotation, separating the initial survey from attendance during works and report updates.

WSI responsibilities: CFA says it produced a WSI for Preston Tower and Doocot and helps clients navigate planning-authority requirements. [3] Have the quotation allocate responsibility for submission, officer comments and revisions. Planning support is not a guarantee of authority approval.

Archive deliverables: CFA describes monitoring that creates an archive record. [3] Ask it to specify deposit destinations, file formats, fees and evidence of submission; creating a record and depositing it should be separate quoted tasks.

Advertisement

Heritage Unlimited

Recording scope: Heritage Unlimited offers Levels 1–4, from basic visual recording through descriptive and analytical records to comprehensive analysis. [4] Heritage Unlimited describes a recording package including archive research, full measured survey and substantial written interpretation. Ask whether attendance when works expose hidden fabric and subsequent record updates are included. [4]

WSI responsibilities: Heritage Unlimited says it submits reports to the local authority and handles condition-discharge submissions. [4] Separately confirm who prepares and submits the WSI, addresses revisions and obtains written agreement; those earlier tasks need their own allocation.

Archive deliverables: Heritage Unlimited says it handles deposits with the relevant Historic Environment Record (HER) and, where appropriate, the Royal Commission archive. [4] Ask it to itemise any locally required OASIS or Archaeology Data Service (ADS) work, formats, fees and submission evidence.

Obtain CFA’s detailed deposit package and Heritage Unlimited’s WSI-preparation and during-works commitments in the quotation. [3][4]

Advertisement

Agree the level—and the analysis behind the drawings

Recording levels describe different depths of investigation, not simply quantities of drawings. [1][2]

  • Level 1: a basic visual record, with photographs and minimal written information identifying the building’s location, age, type, materials and use. [2]
  • Level 2: a descriptive record, covering interior and exterior photography and description, conclusions on development and use, and relevant measured drawings. Camden says the drawn record will not normally be comprehensive. [1][2]
  • Level 3: an analytical account of origins, development and use, supported by evidence, readily accessible documentary sources, measured drawings and comprehensive internal and external photography. It does not necessarily include a detailed documentary search. [1][2]
  • Level 4: comprehensive analysis for buildings of special importance, likely to involve more extensive research, drawings and photography addressing architectural, social, regional and economic significance. [1][2]
Advertisement

These are minimum specifications: the authority may add bespoke requirements. If the condition leaves the level unclear, seek agreement rather than choosing by price alone. [2] The recording guide recommends a scope proportionate to the building’s significance and the proposed works. [5]

Measured geometry is not the whole historical record. Bassetlaw expects written analysis, photography and, where applicable, drawn survey. The report should explain development and significance, distinguish observation from interpretation, and state its scope and limitations. [2]

Ask each quotation to identify documentary research, review of existing records, written analysis, photographic coverage and measured drawings. [1][2][5] The recording guide recommends assessing earlier records before new work begins. [5]

Check local technical requirements too. Camden specifies a minimum 24-megapixel digital SLR, JPEG images for presentation and TIFF for archiving—a local specification, not an England-wide default. [1]

Advertisement

Connect pre-works recording with investigation during works

Make the WSI cover what is visible now and what works may reveal. The recording guide recommends setting out existing knowledge, research gaps, proposed changes, objectives, recording level and methods, while allowing investigation to respond to discoveries. [5]

Ask for a connected programme with two phases:

  • Pre-works recording: document the accessible building and identify areas where coverings or restricted access limit understanding. Camden identifies the pre-development record as the principal objective, while recognising later recording of previously obscured fabric may be needed. [1]
  • During-works recording: identify where stripping-out, alteration or demolition could expose significant evidence and agree monitoring at those stages. [1][5]
Advertisement

Ask the consultant to specify affected areas, contractor notification arrangements, attendance assumptions and access requirements. Agree how additional visits will be priced, who can authorise them and how scope changes will be referred for instructions or approval. These procurement questions support the guide’s emphasis on flexible investigation and contractor communication. [5]

CFA’s Greater Manchester mills project illustrates the approach: the provider describes adapting existing plans, preparing elevation and detail drawings, and undertaking a structural watching brief before and during demolition. That example does not establish what another CFA quotation includes. [3]

Require newly exposed features to be recorded consistently with the initial survey and incorporated into revised interpretation. [5] Treat below-floor archaeological excavation as a separate scope question: the guide recommends established excavation practice, suitably accredited or otherwise qualified personnel, and integration of above- and below-ground findings. [5]

Advertisement

Specify archive deposits to local requirements

Camden and Bassetlaw illustrate why an archive needs its own quotation specification rather than a generic promise to deliver a report. [1][2]

  • Camden: the guidance calls for report deposition through the Online Access to Index of Archaeological Investigations (OASIS) project and preparation of the digital archive for deposition and curation by the Greater London HER and ADS. ADS has strict metadata requirements and charges a fee to include in project costing. The guidance also says a PDF report and JPEG images should routinely be sent to the Greater London HER. [1]
  • Bassetlaw: the record should be accessible through deposit in a permanent archive. Reports can accompany a planning or listed-building-consent application, or support discharge of an approved condition. The council specifies three report copies, with an electronic version counting as one. [2]
Advertisement

Do not assume Camden’s OASIS and ADS arrangements apply in Bassetlaw—or that Bassetlaw’s copy count applies elsewhere. Follow the relevant authority’s requirements and agreed project scope. [1][2]

Ask for an archive schedule listing each recipient, deliverable, file format, metadata task, responsible party, included charge and evidence of submission or acceptance where required. [1][2][5] Consult the receiving archive early: the recording guide recommends this because archive requirements can determine recording formats. [5]

Confirm with either provider that the quotation covers the relevant authority’s archive requirements, including formats, metadata tasks and fees, rather than assuming these are included in its recording or deposit service. [3][4] For a Camden project, specifically check the OASIS, ADS and Greater London HER requirements described above. [1]

Advertisement

Separate report completion from approval and discharge

A delivered PDF, submission receipt and archive deposit are separate milestones—not substitutes for the authority’s decision. [1][2] Use the condition to establish the sequence, then track:

  • Scope and WSI: retain the agreed recording level and investigation scheme, including written approval where the condition requires it. [1][2]
  • Implementation: check the approved programme has been carried out, including required recording during works. [1]
  • Report and archive: obtain the final report and evidence of required deposits. [1][2]
  • Formal submission: retain evidence of what was submitted to support condition discharge. [2]
  • Authority decision: obtain the relevant written decision rather than treating submission as approval. [1]

Heritage Unlimited offers submission and condition-discharge handling. [4] Ask the quotation to name who submits, answers officer queries, revises documents and forwards the authority’s correspondence.

Do not start conditioned works simply because a report has been submitted. [1]

Advertisement

Compare price, programme and coverage

Ask both providers to price the same brief, marking research, survey, WSI work, monitoring, revisions, submissions and archive tasks as included, excluded or separately charged. Those are distinct responsibilities across the published services and local requirements. [1][2][3][4]

The cited provider pages give no fixed prices, and CFA’s page gives no project duration. [3][4] Heritage Unlimited prices individually after reviewing the address, required recording level and condition wording. [4] Heritage Unlimited says there is no statutory licence requirement, but local authorities expect a heritage consultant or buildings archaeologist with formal training and experience in the relevant Historic England guidance. Request evidence of qualifications and insurance, payment and deposit requirements, contract and cancellation terms, and additional-work rates in writing. [4]

Programme: Heritage Unlimited estimates three to four weeks from instruction to final report for a typical Level 2 residential or small-commercial record, five to eight weeks for Level 3, and a project-specific programme agreed at the outset for Level 4. These are provider estimates, not authority approval deadlines. [4]

Enquiries and coverage: Heritage Unlimited says it responds within 24 hours, with most enquiries receiving a written outline approach within that period. It identifies London availability and Colchester work; ask whether it covers the project address. [4] CFA states UK-wide coverage, including England, and directs owners to contact it about their project. [3]

CFA’s published offer emphasises WSI preparation and structural monitoring; Heritage Unlimited’s emphasises level-based recording and deposit/submission handling. [3][4] Choose after the quotation assigns the locally required responsibilities—not from the report price alone.

References

  1. Archaeological Building Recording Guidance Note (camden.gov.uk)
  2. A Guide to Heritage Asset Recording | Bassetlaw District Council (bassetlaw.gov.uk)
  3. Historic Building Survey | CFA Archaeology | UK (cfa-archaeology.co.uk)
  4. Historic Building Recording | Heritage Unlimited (heritageunlimited.co.uk)
  5. Understanding Historic Buildings: A Guide to Good Recording Practice (divio-media.org, 2006)
Advertisement

Similar reads