PMI testing in Australia: scope requirements for metal buyers
When ordering positive material identification (PMI), separate the purchase order’s requirements from buyer-selected checks, then specify the grade question, capable method, item coverage and traceable acceptance records—not merely “PMI required”.[1][3][5]

- Contract-required: Carry through the testing scope, coverage, timing, operator approval and marking provisions invoked by the purchase order or referenced project specifications.[5]
- Buyer-selected, unless already specified: Define the identification question, decisive elements, suitable method, sampling unit, reporting and discrepancy-handling requirements.[1][3]
Check which requirements the purchase order invokes
ASSDA links grade confirmation to the application and consequences of using the wrong alloy. Individual testing of finished LPG valves is its safety-critical example, not a universal coverage rule.[1]
Check the purchase order and referenced specifications before accepting a proposed percentage. BN-SP-UE301, last updated in 2013, applies when invoked by the purchase order or its referenced documents. Its current contractual status is not established by the cited page; use it as a contract-specific example, not as a general Australian requirement.[5] Where incorporated, its provisions include:
- Coverage: 100% PMI of listed critical items, including 100% material and weld coverage for piping/components, valves and heat exchangers including tubes, except that previously PMI-tested and marked pipe-spool materials do not require repeat PMI, and post-prefabrication pipe-material checks are random on both sides of tested welds. It also lists exclusions, so the percentage does not apply indiscriminately to every item.[5]
- Sampling: Statistical batch sampling is discouraged except at prime alloy suppliers handling large numbers of identical items with few clearly visible heat numbers.[5]
- Timing: Testing follows fabrication or erection, preferably before stress relieving, and precedes final release. A receiving check alone does not fulfil this specified post-fabrication requirement.[5]
Write the alloy question before naming the test
“Is this 304-family or 316-family material?” differs from “Does this stainless steel meet the specified low-carbon limit?” The latter needs carbon measurement; portable XRF cannot provide it.[1][2]
List the ordered material standard and grade, decisive elements, acceptance limits and surfaces where testing or marking is restricted. China-based machining supplier Tops Precision’s buyer guide provides this procurement checklist as background, not as an Australian testing-service option.[3]
Keep preliminary identification in perspective. ASSDA says appearance is unreliable and magnetism is inconclusive. A positive molybdenum spot test does not uniquely identify 316 because several other stainless grades also respond.[1]
The proposed method must resolve the intended alloy distinction—not merely return a plausible grade name.[1][2]
Choose a method that measures the decisive elements
Australian testing provider LMATS describes portable XRF as identifying principal alloying elements, but notes limited accuracy and an inability to detect carbon. A displayed grade match is not evidence that every ordered chemistry requirement has been measured.[2][3]
XRF alone cannot confirm the carbon requirement distinguishing 316L from other 316 grades. Specify carbon-capable analysis and request the measured carbon result against the applicable material-specification limit, rather than an “L-grade” label.[2][3]
- Principal alloying elements — portable XRF: Potentially suitable for checking consistency with the ordered alloy. It cannot detect carbon, and its accuracy may be insufficient for the decision. Request measured relevant elements and acceptance limits, not the instrument’s grade label alone.[2][3]
- Specified carbon limit — suitable optical emission spectroscopy (OES): Confirm carbon capability and require the measured result against the applicable limit. Spark OES needs surface preparation and leaves a local test mark, so agree on permitted test surfaces.[3]
- Proposed LIBS testing: Carbon capability varies by instrument and configuration. Request confirmation that the proposed setup measures carbon where needed; the method name alone is insufficient.[3]
- Laboratory chemistry: ASSDA describes acid-digestion Atomic Absorption or ICP analysis as slower, potentially more costly and more complete than spark testing. Carbon requires a separate LECO ignition test. Specify the element list and identify the carbon test separately.[1]
The OES and LIBS capability details above draw on Tops Precision’s background guidance.[3] Resolve contractual terminology before ordering: ASSDA describes spark spectroscopy as useful for carbon-grade distinction, while BN-SP-UE301 rejects “spark testing”. The sources do not reconcile those terms. If that specification applies, obtain agreement on the named method and procedure rather than assuming OES is accepted.[1][5]
Request instrument and operator evidence
Ask for evidence that the proposed setup can answer the grade question—not merely an instrument brand or a “PMI available” statement.[1][2] Include these requirements:
- Method, instrument identification and procedure: Link the proposed setup to the required alloy distinction.[3]
- Elements, units and limits: Identify which decisive elements will be measured and reported against the acceptance limits.[3]
- Reference checks: State which required checks must be recorded with the results.[3]
ASSDA directs buyers towards NATA laboratories, and LMATS states it is NATA-accredited for portable XRF analysis.[1][2] Check the relevant accreditation scope against the method and work ordered; accreditation does not resolve the separate question of whether XRF can measure the decisive elements.[1][2]
Where BN-SP-UE301 is incorporated, operator provisions include company review of experience and references, submission of named inspectors and CVs before work, interpretive ability and any required examination. Its equipment provisions call for portability, access to examination locations and sufficient semi-quantitative elemental evidence, including unexpected incidental elements that could affect metallurgy or welding.[5]
Define coverage and require item-linked results
Define coverage by heat, stock item, production lot or individual component—not simply “one sample per shipment”. Identify included components, relevant welds, test locations and permitted marks. Distinguish coverage selected for the job from percentages imposed by the contract.[3][5]
Require a report containing:
- Identity: Part or stock identifier, heat/lot, purchase order and mill-certificate references.[3][5]
- Test details: Location, date, method, instrument identification, procedure and operator details.[3][5]
- Results: Measured elements and units, applicable acceptance limits and compliance assessment.[3][5]
- Coverage and outcome: Lot size, number examined, identification marking and acceptance/rejection disposition with reasons.[3][5]
Keep physical marks and records aligned. Seather Technology’s traceability guide distinguishes heat identity from commercial/processing lots and heat-treatment lots, which can have different boundaries. Reconcile legible item marks with the certificate type and lot definition ordered—not merely with a certificate showing the expected grade.[4]
Where BN-SP-UE301 applies, accepted pieces require stamping or colour-coding agreed in advance, identification must be maintained through subsequent manufacturing as specified, and reports become permanent inspection records. Its requirement to test and mark every item received without PMI identification is conditional on that specification.[5]
Accept, hold or investigate chemistry and traceability separately
Reconcile coverage, chemistry, item identification and other specified material evidence before release. A satisfactory instrument reading is only part of that decision.[3][4]
- Chemistry meets limits and records are intact: Check that results cover the required items, match their identifiers and heat or lot records, and meet the agreed limits. Reconcile the certificate with the physical material; passing PMI does not replace the complete certification package ordered.[3][4]
- Chemistry is outside limits or inconclusive: Tops Precision recommends segregating material, preserving identification and obtaining authorised technical review and confirmatory analysis under the agreed procedure before release or rejection.[3]
- Chemistry appears acceptable but the heat-number or certificate link is broken: Hold for traceability resolution. Seather explains that a passing reading confirms chemistry only at the tested point; it does not rebuild the documentary chain. Resolve the record discrepancy through the agreed technical disposition.[4]
Under BN-SP-UE301, unacceptable results trigger independent quantitative analysis using a company-acceptable standard ASTM referee method, or submission of another corrective-action plan for approval. Affected or similarly identified lot or shipment items remain unaccepted pending resolution; material outside the applicable specification after independent testing is rejected.[5]
Keep the acceptance boundary clear: chemistry alone does not establish hardness, tensile properties, temper or completed heat treatment. Those require separately specified evidence or testing.[3]
Complete the testing request
Before placing the order, check the scope contains:
- Contract basis: Applicable PO and project documents, material standard and grade, imposed coverage, operator approvals, marking requirements and release hold points.[5]
- Grade question: Decisive elements, acceptance limits and a contract-permitted method capable of measuring them. Include carbon analysis where carbon is decisive.[1][2][3]
- Items and access: Sampling unit, included components and welds, coverage, test locations, preparation and permitted test marks.[3][5]
- Evidence: Relevant instrument, operator and accreditation details, plus reports linking results to items, heat or lot records and the PO.[2][3][5]
- Disposition: Hold points, authorised review and the agreed route for failed or inconclusive chemistry and documentary discrepancies.[3][4][5]
For comparable quotations, include preparation, sampling coverage, reporting and any independent laboratory work in the requested scope.[3] Keep chemistry acceptance and item-to-record linkage as separate checks: neither alone establishes complete material conformity.[3][4]
References
- Testing for Grade Confirmation (asn.au)
- PMI – Positive Material Identification XRF Spectroscopy – LMATS (lmats.au)
- Positive Material Identification For CNC Parts A Buyer Guide (topsbest-precision.com, 2026)
- Superalloy Material Traceability: From Mill Heat to Finished Part (seathertechnology.com, 2026)
- BN-SP-UE301 Specification for Positive Material Identification (PMI) (red-bag.com, 2013)