Asphalt core testing for US owners: acceptance requirements
Define the acceptance question before authorizing testing
To commission asphalt core testing, separate the contract’s acceptance requirements from recommended work-order provisions for traceable sampling and reporting, and apply agency procedures only when they govern the project. [4][5][6]

- Contract requirements: Identify the governing specification, acceptance limits, test methods, represented lot or sublot, and retest provisions. [5][6]
- Recommended commissioning provisions: Document sample locations, identity, custody, report contents, and responsibility for restoring core holes. [5][6]
- Conditional agency requirements: Confirm which agency procedures and laboratory qualifications apply; state DOT rules are not automatic requirements for private paving. [4][5]
Build the work order around the decision the results must support—not simply an instruction to “take cores.” State whether the purpose is investigation, repair planning, or checking newly placed asphalt against the project specification. Name the pavement layer, measurements, laboratory methods, and reference used for any density percentage. [6]
Identify the paving contract, applicable specification, acceptance limits, retest provisions, possible consequences, and person authorized to make the acceptance decision. [5][6] If the acceptance basis is missing, resolve it before commissioning an acceptance-testing assignment rather than choosing a passing number yourself. [6]
FHWA’s 2023 QA report identifies itself as guidance—not a standard, specification, or regulation—and does not establish private-paving acceptance limits. [3] The state procedures likewise do not establish a universal US private-paving passing density percentage or thickness tolerance. [1][4][5]
Assign control of locations and sampling changes
Attach a location sketch with a unique ID for each planned core, and carry those IDs into photographs and field notes. State whether locations target a suspected defect or are intended to represent a defined paving area; that distinction affects what the results can support. [6]
Where the acceptance specification requires random or stratified-random sampling, follow that procedure rather than choosing convenient spots. FHWA describes random acceptance selection as giving every increment within a lot an equal probability of selection, without judgment-based selection. [2][3]
Assign these location-control responsibilities in the work order:
- Location selector: Who establishes sampling points and documents exclusions. [5]
- Field witness: Who verifies selected locations during drilling. [5]
- Change approver: Who may approve relocations, permitted displacement, and extra or replacement cores. [5]
- Record keeper: Who records actual locations and reasons for changes. [5][6]
NJDOT provides a public-project example: an inspector witnesses drilling at Bureau-selected locations, adjustments are restricted and documented, and damaged or unrecoverable air-void/thickness cores require replacement within 2 ft of the original point. These are NJDOT procedures, not default rules for private paving. [5]
Keep original and actual points, exclusions, relocation reasons, and corresponding sample IDs in the location record. Have the evaluator explain whether changes limit interpretation—for example, whether results still represent the intended area or only the sampled locations. [5][6]
Confirm timing, methods, and laboratory qualifications
Before mobilization, document the sampling procedure, laboratory test methods, applicable qualifications, and contractual timing. Identify thickness and density methods separately rather than treating the sampling procedure as the entire laboratory assignment. [4][5][6]
- Match the procedure to the material. Alaska identifies ATM 413 for compacted-mat cores. ATM 401 covers liquid asphalt, while ATM 402 addresses mixture sampling from plants, haul units, and roadways—not compacted cores. [2]
- Keep state timing rules separate. WSDOT’s 2023 SOP 730 gauge-correlation procedure says cores should be obtained by the day after paving and before traffic. [1] NJDOT’s first-lot procedure specifies coring no sooner than 12 hours after paving and delivery to its materials laboratory within 48 hours of completing the lot; cores from additional lots must be delivered within 7 days of completing the lot. [5] These are different procedures, not interchangeable private-project deadlines. [5]
- Match qualifications to the laboratory’s role. Caltrans results used for acceptance or disputes require applicable independent-assurance qualification. Its contractor JMF-testing laboratories and independent dispute-resolution laboratories require both AASHTO re:source and Caltrans Independent Assurance Program qualification. [4]
Caltrans also distinguishes QC roles: standard-process QC used in acceptance requires IAP certification but not AASHTO re:source certification; statistical-pay-factor QC requires IAP certification and recommends re:source certification. Apply those distinctions when that program governs, not as blanket credential requirements for private paving. [4]
Record the sampling window, delivery responsibility, and report-delivery expectation before authorizing the visit. [5][6] The cited agency procedures do not establish a universal private-project deadline or commercial laboratory turnaround. [1][5]
Preserve sample identity through laboratory receipt
Repeat each core’s unique ID on the location sketch, photographs, field notes, sample label, custody record, and final report. [6] Include these custody fields in the work order:
- Sample origin: ID, collection date and time, actual location, and represented lot, sublot, or quantity. [2][5]
- People involved: Sampler, witness, coring company, and drill operator. [2][5]
- Handoffs: Transfers, delivery date, receiving laboratory, and seal identifiers when seals are used. [2][5]
Specify suitable packaging to protect samples against loss, contamination, disturbance, and damage, and assign delivery responsibility. [2][5] Alaska’s mixture-sampling provisions support identification and shipment protection, but its liquid-asphalt container specifications should not be borrowed for pavement cores. [2]
NJDOT’s custody model includes a witnessed sample record identifying the company, operator, date, and seal number, with contractor delivery in a sealed, tamper-proof box to the state laboratory. That is an agency-specific example, not a universal packaging mandate. [5]
Require the report to flag damaged samples or identity discrepancies and explain resulting limits on interpretation. [6]
Specify which layer thickness must be reported
A core’s full length may include older asphalt beneath the new work. Specify whether the laboratory should report total asphalt thickness or the thickness of a named layer, such as the new overlay. [6]
Require each thickness result to identify the sample, relevant layer, units, test method, and any damage or condition limiting interpretation. Identify the plan or contract thickness and applicable tolerance used for comparison. [6]
Core preparation also matters. WSDOT’s gauge-correlation procedure requires cores more than 0.04 ft thicker than plan to be saw-cut to plan thickness before density testing; cores more than 0.04 ft thinner than plan are excluded from the correlation average. Those provisions serve that correlation method—not a general thickness-acceptance rule. [1]
Keep those preparation thresholds separate from the finished pavement’s contractual thickness tolerance. The report should make clear which layer was measured and how the core was treated before testing. [1][6]
Require the density reference and comparison basis
For density, request more than a percentage: specify the measured result and units, test method, reference used to calculate the percentage, represented layer or lot, and project acceptance criterion. A percentage without its reference does not provide the comparison basis needed to evaluate the paving specification. [6]
Percentage of theoretical maximum density is one comparison basis: Caltrans uses it as a core-density characteristic in its statistical-pay-factor process. That example does not supply a universal passing percentage for private paving. Use the reference and acceptance limit required by the governing contract. [4][6]
If nuclear-gauge correlation is included, identify it as a separate, method-specific scope. WSDOT’s procedure uses 10 in-place readings paired with 10 cores at the same locations for the specified gauge and job-mix-formula combination. Those paired samples establish gauge correlation; the count is not a general minimum for private-project acceptance sampling. [1]
Review the report against the acceptance basis
A decision-ready report connects measurements to the sampled pavement and contract criterion. [6] Check for:
- Traceability: Sample IDs matching actual locations and collection records, including dates, sampler or witness, and represented lot or area. [5][6]
- Comparable results: Named layer, units, test method, density reference where relevant, and applicable contract criterion. [6]
- Visible limitations: Damage, identity discrepancies, relocations, and sampling deviations carried into the interpretation. [5][6]
Request a results summary organized by sample and location, layer, result and units, method and reference, contract criterion, and limitations. Ask the report writer to separate observations, interpretation, recommendations, and unknowns. [6]
Keep individual measurements separate from any contract-required lot evaluation. Caltrans, for example, uses distinct standard and statistical-pay-factor acceptance processes; under its standard process, acceptance is based on Caltrans results. [4]
Before testing, assign the report recipient, delivery route, escalation of failing results, and retest authority. NJDOT illustrates formal reporting and closeout through the resident engineer. [5]
Acceptance, retesting, pay adjustment, or replacement should follow the governing specification rather than another agency’s thresholds. [5] If more cores are proposed, require an explanation of the unanswered question those samples would address. [6]
Assign hole restoration and complete the handoff
Before mobilization, put access control, parking or traffic closures, hole-restoration scope and material, and the party responsible for repairs in the work order. Name who verifies completion and who authorizes reopening; do not assume a separate paving contractor is scheduled. [6]
These are recommended commissioning terms, not a nationwide repair standard: NJDOT’s custody procedure does not specify drilled-hole repairs, and Milliken’s owner guidance does not establish a universal repair material or reopening interval. [5][6]
Retain the location sketch, photographs, field notes, custody records, laboratory report, interpretation, restoration confirmation, and next-step recommendation together. [6]
Before authorizing the assignment, check that:
- The acceptance question, governing documents, layer, and comparison criteria are identified. [6]
- Location selection, witnessing, and approval of sampling changes are assigned. [5]
- Test methods, applicable laboratory qualifications, custody controls, and timing are documented. [4][5][6]
- Report contents, recipients, delivery expectations, and handling of failing results are agreed. [5][6]
- Restoration, completion verification, and reopening responsibilities are in writing. [6]
References
- WSDOT SOP 730 (wa.gov, 2023)
- ATM 401 Sampling Asphalt Materials (alaska.gov, 2024)
- A Practice for Including Intelligent Construction Equipment in … (dot.gov, 2023)
- Chapter 4: Construction Details, Section 39: Asphalt Concrete | Caltrans (ca.gov, 2024)
- CONSTRUCTION PROCEDURES HANDBOOK SECTION VI (nj.gov)
- Asphalt Core Samples: What Should You Know Before Testing Your Parking Lot? | Milliken Corporation (millikencorp.com, 2026)