HROUS

Designated Substances Survey: Ontario Owners’ Requirements

Advertisement

For an Ontario alteration tender, separate the designated-substance list and asbestos documents described in Ontario guidance from recommended coverage checks and inaccessible-area records. A survey’s stated investigation boundary—not its title—shows whether it addresses the assemblies the work will disturb. [1][4]

Advertisement
Lab worker analyzes powdered substance in a laboratory setting using safety gear.
  • Owner information duty: EXP’s draft quotes section 30 of Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act as requiring the owner, before beginning a project, to determine whether designated substances are present and prepare a list of those present. [1]
  • Asbestos documents and disclosure: IHSA’s owner-duty guidance describes the asbestos report, location documents and handoff before contracts are finalized. It is an older handoff reference, not standalone confirmation of today’s law. [4]
  • Recommended proposal deliverables: request a work-area cross-reference, explicit exclusions and a location-by-location record of unresolved areas. These supplement the substance list and asbestos documents; they are not presented here as prescribed Ontario schedules.
Advertisement

Define the work before comparing survey proposals

Give each proposer the same alteration drawings and list of affected assemblies. Request written confirmation of the work areas, materials and concealed layers included in the investigation. This is a procurement recommendation, distinct from IHSA’s guidance on showing asbestos-containing material (ACM) locations on drawings, plans and specifications. [4]

EXP’s sample survey has explicit limits on its investigation of concealed assemblies. Compare those exclusions, detailed in the sample-review section below, with the parts of the building the proposed work will disturb. An excluded area is a coverage gap, not a finding that it is free of designated substances. [1]

For each work item, record:

  • Drawing and intervention: identify the room, work area and proposed alteration.
  • Affected assembly: include concealed layers the work will disturb.
  • Proposed coverage: mark it covered, excluded or requiring clarification.
  • Evidence reference: identify the proposal passage or report entry supporting that status.
  • Follow-up: record the question, responsible person and proposed resolution.

Keep this comparison with the proposal review. It makes an undefined investigation boundary visible before the report is relied on for tendering.

Advertisement

Separate asbestos documents from useful extras

Asbestos information described by IHSA

IHSA describes an owner’s asbestos report containing more than a general statement that asbestos was considered. Its guidance calls for: [4]

  • Material status: identification as ACM, not ACM, or material for which work will proceed under O. Reg. 278/05 as though it is ACM. [4]
  • Material characteristics: condition and friability, with friable sprayed-on asbestos distinguished as chrysotile or asbestos other than chrysotile. [4]
  • Location documents: drawings, plans and specifications showing ACM locations. [4]

Check these items individually when assessing an existing report. A narrative conclusion is not the same deliverable as the location documents IHSA describes. [4]

Advertisement

Recommended tender-comparison deliverables

  • Work-area cross-reference: link report entries to the alteration’s rooms, work areas and assemblies.
  • Inaccessible-area register: identify each unresolved location, what was not investigated and why access was limited.
  • Outstanding-items schedule: distinguish missing information and pending investigation from confirmed findings.

Request these explicitly in the proposal. Do not assume a report containing general exclusions will also include a marked-up drawing or location-by-location gap register.

Also distinguish designated substances from a broader hazardous-building-material review. EXP included PCBs, ozone-depleting substances and mould in addition to designated substances; those categories do not expand Ontario’s list of 11 designated substances. [1][3]

Advertisement

Compare sampling rationale, not sample allowances alone

Ask each proposer to identify the suspect materials to be evaluated, explain the sampling allowance and describe how material type, location and condition will be recorded. IHSA describes these elements as part of a designated substances survey. [4]

For asbestos, IHSA describes sampling by a competent worker and analysis under section 3 of O. Reg. 278/05. It says multiple samples are “almost always” required; that is not a universal fixed count for every material or renovation. [4]

Compare proposals on three points:

  • Sampling basis: ask how the proposed approach supports conclusions about the materials being assessed. [4]
  • Historical results: request the underlying sampling records and laboratory reports for any earlier negative results the consultant proposes to rely on. IHSA says historical negatives are usable where enough samples were taken to satisfy section 3. [4]
  • Uninvestigated materials: request a clear distinction between assessed materials and inaccessible materials, particularly where concealed assemblies are excluded. [1]

Keep an assessed historical negative, an uninvestigated material and material deliberately treated as ACM as separate statuses. IHSA describes treating suspect material as ACM without testing as an alternative with adequate controls; its report guidance then calls for stating that work will proceed under the asbestos regulation as though the material is ACM. [4]

Advertisement

Read the Toronto EXP draft against the drawings

EXP’s draft for 1337 Queen Street West, Toronto, describes management, due-diligence and potential real-estate-transaction purposes. It does not establish coverage of a particular renovation drawing set. [1] Use it as an example of an investigation boundary, not proof that a similar survey covers an alteration.

EXP’s methods included visual review of accessible areas, representative bulk sampling and laboratory analysis of suspected asbestos-containing materials, condition assessment of confirmed ACM, representative sampling of suspected lead-containing paints and finishes, and recommendations where required. The investigation was non-destructive and non-intrusive. [1]

Advertisement

Match proposed work against its exclusions:

  • Wall and blockwork interventions: interior and exterior wall cavities and block-wall interiors were outside the investigation. [1]
  • Concealed-ceiling work: areas above concealed ceilings were excluded. [1]
  • Layered-floor work: materials beneath multiple flooring or carpet layers were excluded. [1]

These are scope exclusions, not findings of contamination. They identify where the investigation did not reach. [1]

The sample’s contents list names sample-location tables, laboratory results, confirmed-ACM locations and quantities, photographs and figures. Check the complete report, its draft/final status and the actual appendices against the drawings for your own work; a contents listing is not a substitute for that review. [1]

Advertisement

Establish who receives the findings—and when

Separate the owner’s designated-substance list from the complete asbestos report, and name each recipient route in the tender plan. IHSA describes disclosure before contracts are finalised and onward distribution through the constructor. The sample survey is an example, not a substitute for assigning the statutory roles on this project. [1][4]

IHSA’s May 2023 steel-erection guide also identifies employers engaged directly by the owner as recipients during tendering. That older general guide is not a definitive regulatory guide, but its distinction helps identify direct-owner engagements that could otherwise be missed. [5]

Use a recipient checklist reflecting those distinctions:

Advertisement
  • Owner to prospective constructor: IHSA describes providing the designated-substance list before contracts are finalized. [4]
  • Owner-direct engagements: include employers engaged directly by the owner in the tender-information distribution and receipt log. IHSA’s steel-erection guide expressly identifies this route; do not omit it merely because the employer is outside the selected constructor’s subcontract chain. [5]
  • Constructor onward: IHSA describes the constructor passing the list to contractors and subcontractors. [4]
  • Asbestos report recipients: IHSA separately identifies prospective contractors as recipients of the owner’s asbestos report. [4]

IHSA advises obtaining a signed acknowledgement or other suitable documentation confirming the prospective constructor received the list. Treat this as receipt-documentation advice, not a separate statutory form. [4]

Advertisement

Package the tender information and follow-up

Coordinate the designated-substance list, asbestos owner’s report and ACM location drawings, plans and specifications described by IHSA. Check that the report includes material status, condition, friability and applicable sprayed-on asbestos type. [4]

Attach the work-area cross-reference and unresolved-area register as recommended supplements. Use consistent revision identifiers and a receipt log recording recipients, issue dates and document revisions. These are coordination measures, not additional statutory deliverables.

For City of Toronto work: the City’s designated-substances policy requires substances to which contractor employees may be exposed to be identified in tender documents. This municipal policy is not a requirement for every Ontario owner. [2]

Keep regulatory references accurate. Ontario’s guide assigns construction asbestos exposure to O. Reg. 278/05 and non-asbestos construction exposures to Regulation 833, rather than treating O. Reg. 490/09 as the sole construction rule. [3]

If revised work enters excluded assemblies, the original accessible-area investigation does not establish conditions inside them. [1] As a recommended change-control step, assign someone to compare changed drawings with survey coverage, obtain written clarification and distribute revised findings to affected bidders and contractors.

Where suspect asbestos remains unresolved, IHSA describes further competent investigation or proceeding under the asbestos regulation as though it is ACM, with adequate controls. Resolve this through the project professionals before affected work; do not treat an uninvestigated area as a negative finding. [4]

Before relying on the tender package, check that recipients have the identified-substance information, coverage is traceable to the work areas, and unresolved locations remain visible with assigned follow-up. Do not present a scoped investigation as a guarantee that every substance is absent.

References

  1. 1337 Queen Street West, Toronto, ON (toronto.ca, 2022)
  2. Designated Substances – City of Toronto (toronto.ca)
  3. Overview of the regulation | A guide to designated substances in the workplace | ontario.ca (ontario.ca, 2020)
  4. In Ontario, section 30 of the Occupational Health and (ihsa.ca)
  5. Structural Steel Erection (ihsa.ca, 2023)
Advertisement

Similar reads