Archaeological watching brief requirements for England’s developers
Compare the required scope—not just the attendance rate
A contractor’s quote should cover the work required by the planning condition, local brief and written scheme of investigation (WSI), separating attendance, discovery allowances, post-excavation analysis, reporting and archive deposition.[1][2][3][5]

Use three labels when comparing quotations:
- Required by the project documents: approved monitoring, recording, reporting and archive obligations.[1][2][3]
- Discovery-dependent: additional staffing, specialist work, conservation, analysis or publication needed because of what is found.[1][2]
- Contractual clarification: pricing units, exclusions, responsibility for costs and authority to approve expenditure. Agree these rather than assuming a universal allocation.[1][2][6]
Buckinghamshire’s normal quotation components include WSI production, specified attendance, a final report and a discovery/post-fieldwork contingency. York also expects costings to address Historic Environment Record (HER) consultation, archive requirements and fees, contingency costs and possible publication.[3][5]
South Yorkshire Archaeology Service’s (SYAS) 2023 guidance provides further scope and contingency examples, but says its references must be checked for currency. Use it to inform the comparison, not as confirmation of the requirements applying to a project now.[1]
Ask each contractor to identify the following against the applicable project documents:
- WSI preparation: drafting, background research, consultation and revisions.[2][3]
- Programmed attendance: covered operations, areas, phases and staffing.[1][5]
- Discovery contingencies: additional recording, archaeologists and specialists.[1][2]
- Post-excavation work: finds and sample assessment, analysis, conservation and dating.[1][2]
- Reporting: identify the report, required submissions and any publication allowance.[2][3][5] East Sussex’s historical Elm Court specification included a 4-week deadline for producing a ‘Watching Brief Report’ where limited archaeological remains were recorded.[4]
- Archive deposition: physical and digital preparation, destinations, charges and responsibilities.[1][3]
No monetary rates are given in the cited council documents. East Sussex’s Elm Court specification required a day-rate quotation for that procurement; it is a historical, site-specific example, not a national tariff.[4]
Read the condition and WSI before fixing the scope
A limited monitoring commission may cover only one stage. The Barnsley WSI covered implementation works and explicitly required a further detailed scheme for whole-site mitigation.[6]
Before requesting a firm quotation, assemble:
- The planning condition: identify its approval requirements and the stages it covers.[2][6]
- The applicable local brief and development details: Buckinghamshire says the brief can be used for a quotation and contractors also need development details.[5]
- Groundworks plans and programme: identify the areas, operations and stages requiring monitoring.[1]
- The WSI or project design, where required: make its version and approval status clear.[2][5]
Match the quotation to monitored areas, timetable, recording and sampling methods, outputs, competent staffing and archive arrangements—not merely a number of visits.[1][2][3] Distinguish preparing a WSI, revising an existing scheme and implementing an approved scheme in the appointment.[1][5]
Approval requirements differ locally. Devon requires approval of the WSI by its Historic Environment Team (HET) and the planning authority before development. Buckinghamshire requires agreement of the WSI or project design by its Council Archaeology Service before development starts.[2][5] Neither requirement establishes a national approval turnaround time.
Allocate notices, finds and handover responsibilities
Use a named-responsibility schedule as a contractual tool, not a universal allocation. Specify who performs each task, who pays and what confirms completion.
- WSI preparation and submission: name the preparer and allocate drafting, consultation and revision work; record required written approval.[1][2]
- Authority notification: identify the responsible contact and retain the dated notice. SYAS assigns notification to the archaeological contractor; Devon assigns it to the consultant.[1][2]
- Groundworks coordination: agree the contact connecting the programme manager, groundworks contractor and archaeologist.[1][2]
- Finds care and specialists: allocate handling, records, conservation and specialist commissioning, including expenditure approval.[1][2]
- Museum liaison: name the contact responsible for repository arrangements, accession numbers and archive charges.[2][3]
- Reporting and deposition: allocate submissions, review responses, physical and digital deposits, and evidence of handover.[2][3]
York says the developer should contact an approved museum about archive requirements before WSI drafting, and costings should include archive fees.[3] Do not leave these tasks hidden within an attendance allowance.
Ownership and deposition responsibilities also need checking. As a site-specific example, the Elm Court specification assigned recovered artefact ownership to the landowner and complete archive-deposition arrangements to the applicant.[4]
Price attendance against the programme and notice period
Ask each contractor to identify covered work areas and phases, and whether attendance is continuous or intermittent. SYAS describes normal coverage as all groundworks in agreed areas, including temporary compounds, unless the WSI says otherwise; continuous monitoring means supervision throughout those works.[1]
Check enabling works rather than assuming they are excluded. The Barnsley WSI includes access-road excavation and stripping for soil-storage areas or compounds.[6]
Keep fieldwork notice separate from approval and attendance:
- South Yorkshire: SYAS specifies at least one week’s notice from the archaeological contractor before fieldwork.[1]
- Devon: the consultant must give HET two weeks’ notice unless a shorter period is agreed.[2]
For comparable prices, request the estimated attendance for each groundworks phase, the charging unit, what the allowance covers, and rebooking arrangements if the programme changes. These are contractual clarifications, not published statutory pricing terms.
Elm Court requested day-rate pricing and close liaison with the County Archaeologist over intermittent attendance. That arrangement was specific to that procurement.[4]
Allow recording time in the programme. SYAS specifies sufficient time to investigate and record exposed archaeology; Elm Court required the main contractor to provide reasonable time and resources.[1][4] Attendance should not be priced on an assumption of uninterrupted groundworks.
Define discovery allowances and variation triggers
Distinguish recording covered by the approved WSI from discoveries exceeding its agreed resources or methods. A discovery alone does not establish the commercial basis for a variation.[1][2][6]
Mark additional archaeologists, specialist sampling and dating, finds conservation, post-excavation analysis and publication as included, provisionally allowed for, or subject to separate authorisation. State the allowance or pricing basis.[1][3]
- Significant, complex or deeply stratified remains: Devon requires HET notification and a meeting with the consultant and client/applicant to determine mitigation. Identify how additional attendance and investigation will be priced.[2]
- Discoveries needing specialists: allow for appropriate sampling, assessment and analysis, distinguishing included work from additional authorisation.[1][2]
- Discoveries exceeding WSI resources: the Barnsley scheme requires SYAS advice and, where appropriate, a project-design addendum.[6]
Refer changes to the project archaeologist and archaeological authority, pausing affected work where required. SYAS distinguishes written approval for minor WSI changes from an updated WSI for major changes, submitted to SYAS or the planning authority as appropriate.[1][2]
Human remains require specialist escalation: SYAS calls for agreement before removal or investigation beyond existing excavation limits, with a Ministry of Justice removal licence where necessary.[1]
Name the client’s commercial variation approver separately from the authority’s archaeological approval role. Fix cost responsibility and any contingency cap in the contract rather than assuming a universal allocation.[1][2][6]
Specify analysis, reporting and acceptance
Separate post-excavation assessment and analysis from report production: finds, environmental samples and dating can require specialist work beyond writing up observations.[1][2]
Define the reporting package against the applicable specification, including field records, plans and sections, photographs, specialist results, interpretation and required authority or HER submissions.[1][2] In Devon, little or no archaeology may justify a shorter report—not omission of reporting.[2]
Devon expects the report within three months of fieldwork, subject to specialist or dating results. If substantial delay is anticipated, the contractor must notify HET, agree a revised date and provide an interim report within three months.[2] This reporting deadline is separate from pre-start notification.
Devon also requires current commercial HER information obtained from HET; Heritage Gateway and council-viewer records are not substitutes. A missing data request or reference can delay or potentially prevent report acceptance.[2]
For contract clarity, name who handles review comments and revisions, whether that work is included, and who obtains evidence of acceptance. Submission and acceptance should not be treated as the same milestone.[2]
Make archive handover explicit
List physical deposition, digital deposition, report distribution and OASIS completion as separate deliverables.[2][3]
- Physical archive: name the collecting museum or agreed repository, accession arrangements and selection strategy specifying what will be retained.[1][2][3]
- Digital archive: identify the destination and preparation work. SYAS specifies a data management plan where digital data is expected, covering acquisition through deposition.[1]
- Report distribution: specify required copies and uploads for the authority, HER and client.[2]
- OASIS: allocate project-record completion and report upload rather than leaving them implicit in report writing.[2]
York expects the digital archive to go to the Archaeology Data Service (ADS); a museum deposit should not be treated as completing digital deposition.[3]
Devon requires the collecting museum’s accession number and OASIS identification number in the WSI. HET monitoring continues through archive/finds deposition and satisfactory OASIS completion.[2]
Attach a handover schedule naming who prepares, pays for and deposits each archive stream, and who obtains acknowledgement from recipients. Tie it to the WSI rather than leaving “archiving included” undefined.[1][2][3]
Check the commission without assuming condition fulfilment
Before accepting the quote, check:
- The condition, local brief and relevant WSI are identified, with required approvals accounted for.[2][3]
- Attendance matches the groundworks and authority notice has a named lead.[1][2]
- Discovery allowances, variation triggers and approval responsibilities are explicit.[1][2]
- Reporting and physical and digital archive handover are allocated.[2][3]
Keep fieldwork completion, commissioned outputs and planning-condition fulfilment separate. The Barnsley implementation-only WSI did not cover the whole condition; wider mitigation required a further detailed WSI. Its condition also restricted bringing the development into use until written confirmation of WSI fulfilment or agreement of alternative timescales.[6]
Refer scope changes to the project archaeologist and relevant planning authority, obtaining written approval or an updated WSI where required. Neither the last visit nor the contractor’s invoice establishes fulfilment of the planning condition.[1][2][6]
References
- 1 Revised 11/10/2023 Archaeological Watching Brief Standards & Guidance 1 (sheffield.gov.uk)
- Archaeological Monitoring and Recording – Historic environment (devon.gov.uk)
- Guidance for archaeological work – City of York Council (york.gov.uk)
- SPECIFICATION FOR AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL WATCHING BRIEF DURING THE (eastsussex.gov.uk)
- Generic brief for an archaeological watching brief or small-scale investigation | Buckinghamshire Council (buckinghamshire.gov.uk, 2023)
- Prospect Archaeology Ltd,. 25 West Parade, Lincoln LN1 1NW. Tel 01522 544554 (barnsley.gov.uk)