HROUS

Mobile Shelving for UK Archives: Size the Storage and Compare Installation Quotes

Advertisement

UM Storage vs Rackline: compare the documented provision

UM Storage specifies commissioning and annual inspection provision; Rackline offers certification and project-specific load data.[1][3] Compare their installation quotes against the same usable shelf-metres and retrieval brief, with floor approval and written handover terms as acceptance conditions.

Empty metal storage racks in a spacious industrial warehouse setting.
Advertisement

UM Storage

  • Commissioning evidence: UM says each mobile shelving installation receives a PUWER assessment and a written safe system of work at commissioning.[3]
  • Annual inspection provision: UM specifies annual reinspection under an in-life service contract.[3]
  • Project-specific floor/load documentation: UM says every site survey assesses floor loading; ask for the project-specific load-plan deliverable to be identified in the quotation.[3]

Rackline

  • Rackline says its archive shelving complies with UK loading standards (BS EN 15635) and offers fire-resistant powder-coating options and certification.[1]
  • Annual inspection provision: Ask Rackline to include a maintenance schedule and any inspection-contract provision in its offer.[1]
  • Project-specific floor/load documentation: Rackline says exact load data are supplied for a project; make those data an explicit quotation deliverable.[1]

Ask UM to specify the project-specific load-plan deliverable and Rackline to specify its commissioning handover pack, maintenance schedule and inspection-contract provision.[1][3] This is a difference in documented provision, not evidence of better engineering or faster retrieval.

Advertisement

Specify usable shelf metres from the actual holdings

Start with the holdings and access requirement, rather than asking suppliers to maximise theoretical density. Rackline asks for approximate linear metres of records and available space.[1] Ask it to demonstrate the box-to-linear-metre conversion for your holdings.

Prepare one holdings schedule for both suppliers. Record external box dimensions, storage orientation, quantities, oversized material and measured sample weights. Include the required growth allowance so both proposals accommodate the same holdings.

Ask each supplier to demonstrate container fit and return a capacity schedule showing:

  • Usable dimensions: clear shelf length and depth, vertical clearances and usable storage levels—not overall bay dimensions alone.
  • Container fit: demonstrated boxes per level for each container type and orientation, identifying space unsuitable for the holdings.
  • Capacity allocation: installed usable linear shelf metres, the amount initially occupied and the amount reserved for future holdings, with assumptions and exclusions shown separately.

Rackline refers to layouts supporting an 80% fill rule; treat this as its published statement, not a universal archive standard.[1] Ask what is being measured and how the allowance affects occupied and reserved capacity.

Request a dimensioned layout reconciled to the capacity schedule and proposed aisle arrangement. Make capacity acceptance depend on demonstrated container fit and usable shelf metres, not a box count inferred from a space-saving percentage.

Advertisement

Test simultaneous retrieval, not drive speed alone

Define typical and peak retrieval frequency, concurrent users, the locations they need to reach and acceptable waiting times before asking either supplier for a demonstration.

UM’s FAQ recommends hand-wound shelving for access up to a few times per hour and bays under approximately 25 m, with powered systems recommended for higher-frequency or larger archives.[3] UM separately advertises hand-wound bases for runs up to 30 m: product capability and its operating recommendation are different measures.[3] Ask which applies to the proposed layout and retrieval demand.

As background, Wikipedia describes mobile shelving as wheeled banks on tracks, closing together to open an aisle where needed; it notes that more simultaneous users may require additional aisles, reducing space savings.[2] The article carries citation-quality warnings, so it is not installation approval evidence.[2]

Advertisement

Drive choice alone is not an acceptance test. Ask UM and Rackline for measured aisle-opening times, queue delays and simultaneous-user performance for the proposed system.[1][3]

Request a demonstration using the proposed layout and representative concurrent retrieval tasks. Include requests for different locations, then record:

  • Time taken to open the requested aisle.
  • Waiting time before each user can enter.
  • Overall retrieval-task completion time.

Judge the results against the agreed thresholds rather than accepting an unloaded movement demonstration as sufficient.

UM lists powered-system anti-crush beams, end-aisle photo-eyes and emergency stops, plus aisle locking when hand-wound systems are unattended.[3] Ask both suppliers to document the proposed operating and obstruction controls and demonstrate their response. Assess safety behaviour separately from retrieval performance: protective features are not throughput results.

Advertisement

Assign floor assessment and track responsibilities

Keep structural acceptance with the appointed building professional. The suppliers’ published figures describe different loading measures and are not directly comparable.[1][3]

  • UM Storage: reports approximately 5–8 kN/m² across the rail line for hand-wound systems. It warns that tall bases carrying heavy legal files or council deeds may exceed this and require a floor survey or strengthening; it says every site survey assesses floor loading.[3]
  • Rackline specifies level floors and galvanised or powder-coated finishes to resist damp conditions; its mezzanine installations include reinforced fixings and load assessments to meet building regulations.[1]
Advertisement

A shelf rating does not establish the loads imposed by the proposed loaded carriages and tracks on a particular floor. Request project-specific load information for assessment against the existing structure, rather than treating either supplier’s headline figure as structural approval.[1][3][4]

Ask for a track proposal showing locations, fixing methods, levels, transitions and enabling works. Wikipedia describes surface-mounted and recessed tracks, raised-access-floor integration, ramps and false floors; these are background options, not confirmation that either shortlisted supplier offers every arrangement.[2]

Before accepting the quote, assign responsibility for:

  • Supplying the proposed system’s load information.
  • Assessing the existing floor.
  • Designing track fixings and floor interfaces.
  • Obtaining structural acceptance from the appointed building professional.
  • Specifying and pricing strengthening or enabling works.

IronStor describes professional floor assessment, structural-engineer involvement in track positioning and possible sub-floor bracing.[4] Use this as a prompt to define the engineering scope, not as evidence of what UM or Rackline includes.

Advertisement

Put handover and maintenance deliverables in writing

Make the agreed layout part of a requested handover checklist. Ask for these deliverables in the quotation rather than assuming installation completion includes them:

  • As-installed layout and project-specific load information, with structural approval retained by the appointed building professional.
  • Operating instructions, demonstrated operating and obstruction controls, and recorded user training.
  • Commissioning and inspection records, a defect list with closure evidence, and acceptance sign-off responsibilities.

UM’s commissioning provision comprises a PUWER assessment and written safe system of work.[3] Its annual checks cover brake function, anti-crush sensors, track condition, base rolling resistance and the load-bearing structure, with red/amber/green reports.[3]

Advertisement

UM says failed items receive same-day quotations and repairs within an agreed SLA.[3] Obtain the SLA duration, minimum service term and annual maintenance price alongside the inspection scope and arrangements for addressing defects.

For Rackline, ask for the scope of its available certification and project load data, plus the commissioning process, maintenance schedule and inspection-contract availability.[1] Confirm the complete handover package in the quotation.

For replacement or relocation, request written terms for dismantling, reinstallation, reassessment, recommissioning and warranty implications. UM describes box-by-box labelling, chain-of-custody records, sequential reloading and an audit trail for archive moves.[3] These are records-moving provisions, not confirmation that relocating the shelving itself is included.

Advertisement

Compare installed scope and commercial terms

Neither Rackline’s nor UM Storage’s cited archive page states a mobile-system purchase price.[1][3] Compare itemised quotations on the same scope rather than using an assumed market rate.

  • Rackline: offers a free, no-obligation site survey, space plan and quotation; manufacture and installation timing depends on specification, workload and bay count.[1] Ask for written confirmation of installation and support coverage for the site.
  • UM Storage offers free site surveys and CAD layouts and advertises quotations within 24 hours. It also advertises contact availability 24/7 and £10M public liability insurance.[3] It explicitly offers nationwide UK installation.[3]
Advertisement

Give both suppliers the same pricing schedule. Request separate prices and clear inclusions or exclusions for shelving, tracks, delivery, installation, enabling works, electrical work where relevant, archive handling, commissioning and ongoing service. Identify work assigned to the purchaser or another contractor.

Request written VAT treatment, payment milestones, quotation validity, programme dependencies, variation rules, warranty, cancellation and refund terms. Have the quotation distinguish delivery from completed installation and handover, and identify survey findings or preparatory works that could change the price or programme.

Choose against four acceptance checks

Return incomplete proposals for clarification before comparing totals. Use these checks as a purchasing framework:

  • Capacity: the layout demonstrates the requested usable shelf metres for the holdings, occupancy and growth allowance.
  • Access: a demonstration against the peak retrieval brief shows acceptable aisle availability and waiting times.
  • Structure: the appointed building professional accepts the floor-and-track proposal and its project load information.
  • Handover: installation, commissioning, operating records and ongoing service obligations are agreed in writing.

Keep an evidence log recording each requirement, the supplier’s response, its supporting drawing or document, and unresolved conditions. UM’s published commissioning and annual inspection provision gives a starting point for evaluating in-life support; Rackline’s available certification and exact project load data give a starting point for assessing those deliverables.[1][3] Neither replaces agreement on the complete installation scope.

References

  1. Archive Shelving & Archive Storage Solutions UK | Rackline (rackline.com)
  2. Mobile shelving – Wikipedia (wikipedia.org)
  3. Mobile Shelving Archives & Records Storage UK | UM Storage (umstoragesystems.co.uk)
  4. Mobile Shelving: The Librarian’s Secret Weapon – Ironstor Storage Solutions (ironstor.co.uk)
Advertisement

Similar reads